Smith, Kennedy (1922-1996)
Early Life and Family Background
Kennedy Smith was born in 1922 into a family that combined industrial entrepreneurship with reform politics. When Kennedy was a boy, his father, Raymond Templeton Smith, founded Ben Venue Laboratories in Bedford, Ohio, a pharmaceutical company that would later play a central role in Kennedy’s life. His mother, Eliza Jane Kennedy Smith, was a prominent civic reformer in Pittsburgh and founder and president of the Allegheny County League of Women Voters.
Reflecting both intellectual independence and religious reserve, Kennedy’s parents did not have him baptized as an infant. Religious affiliation remained an open question well into his adulthood.
Education and Formative Years
Kennedy’s early education was accelerated by circumstance. An older brother suffered from rheumatic fever and was educated at home; Kennedy joined in the tutoring and advanced rapidly. When he entered Arnold High School, he skipped two grades and graduated at the age of fourteen in 193.
Believing him too young to enter Harvard immediately, his parents sent him to Institut Le Rosey in Switzerland for the 1938–1939 academic year. There he encountered a rare concentration of international elites on the eve of war. Among his classmates were Rainier, the future Prince of Monaco. Reza Pahlavi, later Shah of Iran was the year ahead of him. . As Europe moved toward catastrophe, students listened to radio broadcasts of Adolf Hitler’s speeches, sometimes hearing them translated simultaneously by another student in the room. These experiences left Kennedy with a lasting awareness of the fragility of civil institutions and the consequences of political corruption.
He returned to the East and enrolled at Harvard College. With America’s entry into World War II, academic programs were compressed, and he completed his undergraduate degree in three years.
Military Service and Baptism
In 1943 Kennedy enlisted in the United States Navy and trained as a Corsair pilot in preparation for the planned invasion of Japan. Shortly before deployment, his aunt, Helen van Orsdel Smith, persuaded him to be baptized in the Episcopal Church. When asked by the priest whether he believed the Creed, Kennedy replied candidly that he was unsure. His sponsor intervened, stating that he believed it, which the priest accepted. The episode became a family anecdote, illustrating Kennedy’s intellectual honesty.
Japan’s surrender ended the need for invasion, and Kennedy returned to civilian life.
Marriage and Early Adulthood
While stationed in Corpus Christi, Texas, Kennedy met Radioman Mary Elizabeth Rutter through a mutual friend of the Smith and Rutter families. They married in February 1945 in a Catholic ceremony in the Manhattan apartment of Mary’s aunt Virginia.
Kennedy enrolled in Harvard Law School. The couple lived on Beacon Hill, where Mary Elizabeth ran a boarding house while raising their first two children. This period combined legal study, domestic enterprise, and the early responsibilities of a growing family.
After graduating from law school, Kennedy returned to Pittsburgh and 5834 Walnut Street in Shadyside.
The Jean Brusco Case and Police Reform
Almost immediately after settling on Walnut Street, in 1949 Kennedy and his wife were confronted with the consequences of the very political failures against which the Smith and Kennedy families had long campaigned. In November 1949, their neighbor, Jean Brusco, was brutally assaulted and murdered outside her home. Despite witnesses and immediate calls to the police, officers failed even to locate her body that night; it was discovered the following morning by a milkman.
The murder exposed profound failures in Pittsburgh’s police system: misdirected patrols, confused dispatching, suppressed or misfiled complaints, and the dominance of ward politics over public safety. These failures were not merely local scandal. In 1950, the Jean Brusco case was discussed at length in the Congressional Record as a national example of the dangers of politically controlled policing.
For Kennedy Smith, the case was not abstract. It occurred steps from his home and reinforced his conviction that law without honest administration was meaningless. The Brusco murder became a touchstone in his understanding of justice and directly informed his later decision to accept judicial office.
Challenge to Police Administration
At a public citizens’ meeting held at Lanley School in Pittsburgh, Smith directly confronted Police Superintendent Harvey J. Scott about the department’s practice of concealing crime reports in what officers informally called the “butcher book”—a miscellaneous record in which complaints were entered but often not formally reported to police headquarters unless an arrest occurred.
Smith asked Scott how he could justify “hiding crime reports—‘butcher book procedure.’” Scott replied that other cities did the same and that he did not worry if Pittsburgh’s reputation suffered. Smith pressed further, asking whether the practice constituted good police method, but the superintendent offered no substantive answer.
This exchange became widely quoted in discussions of Pittsburgh policing and was later reproduced in national commentary criticizing political interference in police departments.
Role in the Citizens’ Reform Effort
Smith was associated with the Shadyside Residents’ Committee, a civic organization formed to demand stronger police protection in the East End neighborhoods. The group had already been petitioning city officials for increased foot patrols and administrative reform before the Brusco murder.
After the killing, the committee intensified its efforts. Smith’s wife, publicly spoke for the organization and sharply criticized the police administration. Together with other civic leaders such as Mrs. Louise G. Bond and members of the League of Women Voters, the group organized petitions, public meetings, and press statements calling attention to the city’s crime problem.
Central Reform Argument
Smith and his allies argued that the core problem was political control of the police department, particularly the influence of ward political organizations over hiring, promotion, and assignments. According to reformers, this system undermined professionalism and discouraged accurate crime reporting.
Their reform proposals included:
eliminating ward-based political patronage in police hiring and promotion
ending tolerance of vice and gambling operations protected by political influence
building a professional, non-political police force with adequate patrol strength
Broader Significance
The Brusco murder and the Shadyside protest movement helped bring public attention to longstanding criticisms of the Pittsburgh Bureau of Police, including poor communications procedures and fragmented crime reporting. The controversy was cited in national discussions of urban policing and appeared in the Congressional Record as an example of problems created by political patronage in law enforcement.
Within Pittsburgh civic life, Kennedy Smith’s intervention represents a typical mid-twentieth-century form of neighborhood-based reform activism, in which professional residents—lawyers, merchants, and civic leaders—organized public pressure to modernize municipal institutions.
Legal Career and Judicial Service
After returning to Pittsburgh, Kennedy became a Assistant District Attorney in the anti-racketeering division of the State’s Attorney’s office. Kennedy practiced law in Pittsburgh, first with Baker, Watts & Woods and later as a founding partner of Kline & Smith, with offices in the Grant Building. He also served earlier as a special deputy attorney general.
In December 1970, Governor Raymond P. Shafer appointed Kennedy Smith justice of the peace for Pittsburgh’s 29th District, succeeding Joseph P. Rigby upon Rigby’s resignation. The district included Shadyside, Bloomfield, and parts of East Liberty. He subsequently stood for election and was re-elected, serving continuously through 1981.
Smith emphasized accessibility and practicality in office, stating that he sought to make the magistrate’s court as open and accessible to the public as possible. His judicial service overlapped with his leadership at Ben Venue Laboratories, reflecting the part-time nature of magistrate service at the time and his capacity to balance public duty with executive responsibility.
If his children had finished their homework they were allowed to attend the night court of the father, the Squire of East Liberty. Mrs. Smith was probably not aware of the colorful participants in some of the cases, including transvestites and stalkers.
Business Leadership at Ben Venue Laboratories
Following his father’s death in 1967, Kennedy divided responsibilities with his brother and became president of Ben Venue Laboratories. He oversaw significant expansion and entered into agreements with the National Institutes of Health to manufacture small batches of experimental oncological drugs, a demanding niche requiring technical precision and regulatory rigor.
Under his leadership, Ben Venue became a major producer of generic pharmaceuticals and injectable drugs. As his health began to fail, his son Edward Caldwell Smith increasingly assisted in managing the company. Ben Venue was eventually sold to Boehringer Ingelheim in a transaction notable enough to be reported in the Wall Street Journal.
Later Years, Religion, and Death
As business and legal responsibilities evolved, Kennedy moved from the Miller estate at Emerson Point to a farmhouse known as Waterhole Cove, which he renovated and expanded. It became the family’s summer gathering place, visited by children, grandchildren, and friends. There he kept the motor yacht, the Osona, which he has inherited, and was named after an Indian woman who had saved the life of a relative. Kennedy preferred sailing, and purchased a catamaran and the Cygnus.
In 1995, late in life, Kennedy converted to Catholicism, joining Holy Spirit Byzantine Catholic Church in Shadyside, a decision reflecting a long interior journey rather than a sudden change.
Kennedy Smith died in 1996. His life joined family legacy, civic reform, judicial service, and industrial leadership, shaped decisively by an early and intimate encounter with the costs of political corruption and the demands of justice.