Early Life and Family Background

Bradhurst Schieffelin was born into one of New York’s oldest pharmaceutical families. His grandfather, Jacob Schieffelin, had founded the drug house of Schieffelin Brothers, and his father, Henry Hamilton Schieffelin, maintained its position as one of the leading wholesale pharmaceutical firms in the city. Bradhurst grew up within a large and prosperous kinship network that combined commercial success, public respectability, and substantial inherited wealth.

Career and Financial Ventures

Although raised for participation in the family drug business, Schieffelin’s own career diverged into a series of speculative and philanthropic pursuits. He inherited a large fortune and valuable interests in Schieffelin Brothers, and for a time was an active member of the firm. During the petroleum boom of the 1860s he became one of the earliest New Yorkers to invest heavily in refined oil, purchasing crude in substantial quantities. His enthusiasm for the venture far exceeded its profits, and these early speculations marked the beginning of a long financial decline.

Later in life he invested money in the Metropolitan Publishing Company and its associated spiritualist and reformist periodical, House and Home. Described by the press as a “quiet philanthropist,” Schieffelin supported various reform movements, including Shelters for Tramps in the Bowery, and gave freely to schemes presented by acquaintances and spiritualist associates. These ventures consistently failed, and much of his remaining estate was gradually dissipated. By the late 1870s his brothers controlled the residue of his fortune, including a trust created for the benefit of one of his daughters.

Politics

He ran in 1883 as a candidate for state senate of the People’s Party, which he had founded. He received one vote. With Charles O’Conor and Horace Greeley, he formulated a petition introduced into the United States Congress by Roscoe Conkling for the prevention of the appropriation for the use of religious corporations of public moneys or property. He believed that no republic can exist where wealth is allowed to accumulate in the hands of a small minority, and favored a law limiting inheritance

Married Life and Domestic Difficulties

His domestic life was marked by early bereavement. His first wife, Elenor McGinn, the sister of one of his trickmen, died after bearing two daughters, and his second wife, a Canadian boarding-house keeper, also died before the early 1880s. Schieffelin was widely reported to have been sincerely attached to both women, and their deaths left him emotionally and socially vulnerable.

In 1883 he married (legally invalidly) Lucy Cady Dodge, who was then widely known under an array of aliases, including Mrs. Faust, Mrs. Hewitt, Maud Raymond, and Mrs. Chapman. She had married a Harvard graduate in youth, been widowed, and later wed Nathaniel Hewitt of a wealthy Vermont family.

She was active in the social scene in Washington, D. C .and then moved to Cleveland. Hewitt (perhaps because of the move to Cleveland) took to whiskey and stock speculation and lost his fortune. They separated. He unsuccessfully sued for divorce in Connecticut; he then swore he would get a divorce if he had to found a town to get it in. Hewitt founded the town of Hewitt in Colorado and Lucy said he told her he had gotten a divorce there. But she was never legally divorced, a fact established publicly during the ensuing scandal.

Lucy had drifted into spiritualist circles in New York and Washington, where she became acquainted with Mrs. Spence, a medium; Mrs. Spence introduced her to Schieffelin while attempting to secure him as a husband for her own daughter, for whose musical education Schieffelin was paying. Lucy spent $1,000 for her trousseau with E.J. Denning and Co. Mrs. Spence sued the new Mrs. Schieffelin for $10,000 for her work in bringing about the match.

The marriage, contracted in Hoboken on 24 May 1883, was socially recognized but legally void. The household at Long Branch, New Jersey, soon became divided. Lucy and Bradhurst went to live in a villa in a spiritualist colony on Long Island On the advice of counsel, Schieffelin lived apart from Lucy in the gardener’s cottage while she remained in the main house. Their relations were further strained by Lucy’s efforts to gain control of his remaining property and by her involvement in spiritualist publishing ventures financed by him.

The Bigamy Scandal, 1883–1886

In 1885–1886 the scandal that had long circulated in whispers in Long Branch society broke into the open. Acting on a complaint by Herbert W. Beecher, a member of the prominent Brooklyn family and a former associate in the publishing company, Lucy was indicted for bigamy by a Hudson County, New Jersey grand jury. Detectives arrested her at the Schieffelin mansion near midnight after a dramatic pursuit through the house. She was hiding under bedclothes in the cupola of a building on the when the detectives showed up at night to arrest her. She told them to go downstairs and enjoy whiskey and cigars until the morning when they would have breakfast like white people. She was held on bail, which her husband could not secure.

The ensuing hearings produced a stream of revelations. Hewitt confirmed in writing that he had never procured a divorce, and no court papers supporting Lucy’s claim of a Colorado decree could be found. Lucy offered lengthy and shifting explanations of her marital history and displayed numerous aliases and inconsistencies under questioning. The Schieffelin family, anxious to protect their reputation and the assets held in trust, lent support to the prosecution. Although a later nolle prosequi ended the case, the marriage to Schieffelin was recognized as invalid.

In 1889 the dry goods company E.J. Denning and Co., the source of Lucy’s trousseau, had a judgment against Bradhurst and sought to collect, but his brother Samuel Bradhurst Schieffelin testified that Bradhurst had no means, no interest in the family company, and was supported by an allowance of $25 a week from his brothers.

Later Years

After the scandal receded, Schieffelin lived quietly at his estate in Richmond, Staten Island, supported by the family trust and assisted by relatives. His daughters remained abroad for much of their adult lives. Although the 1883 marriage to Lucy had been legally void, she remained in his household during his later years, and contemporary newspapers—including his obituary—described her as his widow for social purposes, reflecting the convention of acknowledging the woman who lived with a man at the time of his death as his spouse regardless of the earlier legal controversy.

Death

Bradhurst Schieffelin died at his home in Staten Island in 1909. His obituary credited him with having introduced refined petroleum commercially to New York, and noted his longstanding philanthropic impulses. He was survived by the woman publicly regarded as his widow, Lucy Cady Dodge, and by his two daughters, who were residing in Europe at the time of his death. He was buried in the Moravian Cemetery in New Dorp, Staten Island.