Shore Acres

The house in the middle front on the bluff above the Narrows is Shore Acres. It is adjacent to Fort Wadsworth and was a landmark to those entering New York Harbor.
Location: Fort Wadsworth, Staten Island.
Built: 1850s and later additions.
Architect: Unknown.
Period Owner / Occupant Key Developments
1850s–1863 Claude Gignoux Original construction on the point above the Narrows.
1863–1869 Régis Gignoux Property used by the Hudson River School painter.
1869–1890 J. Frank Emmons Expansion of the home; period of SIRT Railroad presidency.
1890–1912 James Henry Alexandre Addition of the northern wing; stables for thoroughbred horses.
1927–1929 Demolition: Mansion removed; site subdivided by Cornelius Kolff.
1960s–Presen Verrazzano Bridge Site occupied by the bridge
History
The history of Shore Acres is bound up with the history of the French merchants of New York.
Claude-Thaddée-Népomucène Gignoux (1806-1883) was born in Lyons, France, a center of the silk industry. On 1832 He came to New York and became a merchant in silks. He married a woman from England, Harriet Christmas. In 1838 Claude returned to France to present his wife to his family. Accompanying them was her sister Elizabeth Christmas.
Marie François-Régis Gignoux (1814-1882), the younger brother of Claude, was studying at the l’Ecole des Beaux-Arts in Paris and fell in love with Elizabeth. When the others returned to New York, Regis followed them and proposed to Elizabeth. They married in 1840. Regis intended to return to France to continue his studies in art.
Her father, Charles Christmas, a prosperous financer, did not want to be separated from his daughter, and offered Regis a house and garden in Brooklyn. He became a prominent member of the Hudson River School of landscape painters and specialized in snow scenes. He was President of the Brooklyn Art Academy. He taught other artists, including George Inness, John Lafarge, and Charles Dormon Robinson.
By 1844, Gignoux had opened a studio in New York City and became one of the first artists to join the famous Tenth Street Studio in Manhattan, where other members included Albert Bierstadt, Frederic Church, Jasper Francis Cropsey, and John Frederick Kensett.
His brother Claude was a resident of Staten Island. He and his wife and seven children lived in a house at the point above the Narrows between Staten Island and Manhattan. There he built a house; in the 1860 census his real estate was valued at $50,000. Claude returned to France in 1863, when he may have sold or given the estate to his brother Regis. The New York Times attributed the estate to Regis, and he may have been the owner briefly after his brother Claude returned to France and before he returned to France.
In 1869 Charles Christmas died and Regis and his wife returned to France. Presumably at this time Regis sold it to J. Frank Emmons, who expanded it. Emmons was the president of the States Island Rapid Transit Railroad Company.

After 1890 James Henry Alexandre was the owner and added the northern wing. He renamed it Shore Acres. He summered there; he wintered in his town house first at 10 West 32nd Street in Manhattan and later at 35 East 67th Street.

The Alexandre family brought a Gilded Age lifestyle to Shore Acres that was more than just a home—it was a base for high-society sports.
Thoroughbred Interests: James Henry Alexandre was deeply involved in the aristocratic sports of horse racing and polo. He kept a stable of thoroughbreds on the Staten Island grounds and was a prominent member of the Richmond County Hunt Club and the Coney Island Jockey Club.
Equestrian interests: Alexandre also kept enough horses that a house party of ?? could go riding
Shipping; Alexandre was the heir of the Alexandre Line fortune.
Yachts: Alexandre first owned the Vision and in 1890 bought the Sappho,a 96’ steam yacht with a 15’ bean that drew 6 ½ feet. It had been built in 1879. He used it to commute to his office in Manhattan. Its master was Captain J. William Facks. Family legend is that the Sappho went to Hollywood where it played the role of an elegant yacht.
Social Hub: Alexandre hosted numerus house parties and family social events.
Wedding: On November 9, 1899, the Alexandres hosted the wedding of their daughter, Gertrude Jerome Alexandre, to Samuel Adams Clark.
The New York Tribune reported: “One of the prettiest and most notable weddings of the present month, celebrated in the suburb, was that of Miss Gertrude Jereome, daughter of J. Harry Alexandre, who was married to Samuel Adams Clark, a son of Colonel J. S. H. Clark, of Newark, and a nephew of Bishop Clark, of Rhode Island, at 12.30 o’clock yesterday afternoon at the country home of the bride’s father. Shore Acres, Rosebank station, The guests were taken at Staten Island from New-York on a special steamer, the Favorite, which the bride’s party at 11.30 o’clock and landed at the wharf directly in front of Mr. Alexandre’s handsome place. The house was entirely decorated with palms, chrysanthemums and roses, except in the billiard room, where the ceremony was performed by the Rev. Thomas J. Ducey, rector of St. Leo’s Roman Catholic Church, East Orange. The double room in this house was a sanctuary formed of flowers and the ceremony was performed under a bell of white roses. The bride, who entered with her father, wore a gown of white satin, trimmed with point lace. Her veil, the same worn by her mother, was also of lace. Her only ornament was a diamond cross, which belonged to her mother, who was a daughter of the late Thomas Jerome. Her bridesmaids were white orchids.”
The New York Times reported: “The largest and most fashionable country wedding of the season, that of Samuel Adams Clark of Newark, N. J., and Miss Gertrude Jerome Alexandre, daughter of J. Henry Alexandre, was celebrated yesterday noon at the country house of the bride’s father, Shore Acres, near Fort Wadsworth, S. I. Both Mr. Clark and Miss Alexandre are members of the younger dancing class set, and the wedding has attracted a large amount of attention and interest for some weeks past. The bride’s mother, who died some years ago, was Miss Gertrude Jerome, a daughter of the late Thomas Jerome, and a sister of Mrs. Clarence Dinsmore. She has been brought up from a little girl by her stepmother, who was Miss Elizabeth Lawrence of Bay Side, L. I., a sister of Mrs. Lieut. McKinstry and Mrs. Foxhall Keene.
There are few more beautiful country places in the suburbs of New York than Shore Acres, once the home of the old landscape artist, Regis Gignoux, and the weather of yesterday was ideal for a country wedding, so that its scenes will linger long in the memory of the fortunate guests. Not only were Staten Island and Newark society largely represented at the wedding, but a special ferryboat which left this city at 11:10 A. M. took down nearly 200 guests from town. The ceremony was performed in the large parlor of Shore Acres, which was decorated with palms, ferns, and Autumn leaves, soon after noon, and when the guests had all assembled. The mellow rays of the Indian Summer sun shone through the windows upon the bridal party, who, when they turned their eyes eastward, could look out upon the golden waters of the Narrows just below them and covered with vessels passing in and out of the harbor”
And the wedding was also misreported, according to the New York Times: “The week brought several weddings, the most socially important of which was that of Mr. Samuel Adams Clark of Newark, N. J., a nephew of Bishop Clark of Rhode Island, and Miss Gertrude Jerome Alexandre, and which took place on Thursday at “Shore Acres,” Mr. Alexandre’s country place, at Staten Island. A rather amusing incident of this wedding was the seeming ignorance on the part of the press as to who married Mr. and Mrs. Clark. One newspaper announced that the officiating clergyman was the Rev. Dr. John C. Eccleston, rector emeritus of St. John’s Episcopal Church at Clifton, while the remaining journals did not give the name of any minister at all. As a matter of fact, the ceremony was performed, Miss Alexandre being a Roman Catholic, by no other than the well-known Father Thomas J. Ducey of the parish church the Alexandres have been parishioners for many years.”
Family Stories
The prelude to another wedding began in the stables of Shore Acres. Nathaniel Edward Caldwell Rutter and Mary Elizabeth Alexandre shared an interest in horses. During one of his visits to Shore Acres, Nathaniel and Mary Elizabth were in the stables. Nathaniel apparently thought this was a romantic spot, because, as they both sat on the edge of a horse trough, he proposed marriage to her. She accepted. She said he was so surprised he fell it. He said she pushed him. But the marriage was celebrated at St. Agnes Church in Manhattan and produced five children.
Grounds
The grounds of the estate were noteworthy. When local naturalist William T. Davis documented the waterways of Staten Island, he was given access to the property, whose pond was known by then as Lake Alexandre.

City photographer Percy Loomis Sperr also visited Shore Acres, capturing its lakeside pergola in 1926, 1930 and 1934.

In 1893 Alexandre sold about 27 acres to the Federal government for the expansion of Fort Wadsworth. The house was demolished in 1927 and the estate was sold in early 1929 (before the Crash) and divided into smaller estates. Then the Verrazano bridge was constructed over the site.

Today, the area is designated as a Special Natural Area District by New York City to protect the remaining natural features, including the flora and bodies of water that naturalists like William T. Davis once studied on the private estate.

Brooklyn is in the foreground. Shore Acres was at the far end of the bridge.