Early Life

He was born 23 March 1810 in Pennsylvania, likely into the Scots-Irish Presbyterian population that had settled Westmoreland and Allegheny Counties in the late eighteenth century. Records do not yet identify his parents, but his later affiliations suggest a family well integrated into the civic and religious life of western Pennsylvania.

Marriage and Family

Smith married Sarah Ann Crawford in January 1840. Their household grew steadily over the next two decades, producing six children, all connected to the Westmoreland–Allegheny region through birth, marriage, or burial records. These children form the solidly documented Smith–Crawford line from which the later Smith generation descends.

Residences

The Smith family lived in the western Pennsylvania corridor linking Westmoreland County to Pittsburgh. Records place them at various times in Derry Township, Youngstown, and the Third (later Fifth) Ward of Pittsburgh. At the time of his death in 1870, Smith was living at 54 Chatham Street in downtown Pittsburgh, a dense business district near the Monongahela riverfront.

Public Life and Political Activity

Smith played an active role in Pittsburgh politics for more than twenty years. In 1848 and again in 1849 he was elected as a Whig to the Common Council from the Third Ward, representing a district undergoing rapid commercial and industrial expansion. He continued to support the Whig Party through the early 1850s, appearing at Whig rallies in 1852.

As the Whig Party disintegrated and its former members formed the nucleus of the Republican Party, Smith followed the mainstream of his peers. In 1857 he served as Inspector of Elections for the Second Precinct of the Third Ward. During the Civil War era he appeared on the “Union” (Republican) ticket; in 1865 he was nominated by the Union Ward organization for Common Council from the Third Ward. In 1868 he was designated by the Republican City Committee as an election officer and was nominated by Republicans in the Fifth (formerly Third) Ward as assessor. These recurring appointments indicate a man firmly embedded in the ward-level apparatus that organized and managed elections in nineteenth-century Pittsburgh.

Religious and Civic Service

In 1860 Smith served as a trustee of the First Reformed Presbyterian Church of Pittsburgh, a congregation founded in 1800 and long central to the city’s Covenanter (Reformed Presbyterian) community. As a trustee he would have participated in the management of property, finance, and congregational affairs, responsibilities that align well with his known occupation in construction and contracting.

Occupation: Builder and Contractor

Newspaper references identify Smith as a builder or construction contractor active in mid-nineteenth-century Pittsburgh. In 1866 he built an extension to the Monongahela House, one of the city’s principal hotels and social hubs. This commission indicates professional standing and the ability to secure major commercial contracts in the city center.

Later accounts of Pittsburgh public works attribute the construction of the original stations of the Monongahela Incline (opened 1870) to a “local carpenter, R. J. Smith.” While the name is too common to permit certainty, the timing, location, and occupation make it plausible that this was the same Robert J. Smith who worked on the Monongahela House extension. The identification remains probable but unconfirmed.

Death

Robert J. Smith died 30 October 1870 in Youngstown, Westmoreland County, but was still maintaining residence at 54 Chatham Street in Pittsburgh. His widow, Sarah Ann Crawford Smith, survived him by two decades, dying in 1890.